The Secret Behind The Second Wall

My parents bought a home that used to be a funeral parlor almost 100 years ago. Dad had never questioned why there was a second wall that went nowhere and when there was a bust pipe they finally had to cut it open. Inside we found something none of us ever expected—a small room, completely sealed, like it had been forgotten by time itself.

The air was stale, thick like dust had been holding its breath for decades. The room had no windows, only a cracked mirror on the far wall and an old wooden chair in the middle. On the chair sat a dusty leather-bound journal, its pages yellowed and curling at the edges.

Dad picked it up carefully. “Looks old,” he said, brushing off a cobweb. “Should we read it?”

Mom hesitated, but curiosity got the better of her. “If this belonged to whoever ran the funeral parlor, maybe it has some history. Could be worth something.”

They started flipping through the pages that night, after dinner. It wasn’t a typical journal. It read more like confessions—deep, personal, and unsettling. The entries were dated between 1926 and 1932, and they were signed by someone named Arthur Bellamy.

Arthur was the original owner of the funeral parlor. He wrote about his daily life, embalming bodies, comforting grieving families, but also about something stranger—visits he claimed to have from people who weren’t dead yet.

At first, we thought it was some metaphor or maybe grief-induced hallucinations. But he was clear: he claimed that every now and then, someone would appear in the mirror in that sealed room, and within days, they’d die. According to him, the mirror was cursed.

We laughed nervously. The whole thing felt like an old ghost story, something to creep kids out. But Mom didn’t laugh. “The mirror’s still there,” she said. “Same one.”

I was 17 at the time and already deep into weird internet forums about haunted objects and urban legends. This was gold for me. I took pictures, posted in a couple of groups, and got a lot of attention. People begged me to livestream near the mirror, try rituals, say certain things in the room.

But Dad was firm. “We’re sealing it back up. It’s just a story.”

Except, we didn’t. The busted pipe meant we had to keep the wall open for a bit. Plumbers were in and out. And the mirror just sat there.

Then, the dreams started.

It began with Mom. She said she saw a woman in old-fashioned clothing standing beside her bed. The woman didn’t speak. She just looked… sad. Then Dad saw the same woman, standing in the hallway at 3 AM.

I joked that maybe she was our houseguest now. But I didn’t joke when I started seeing her too.

She was always near the mirror. Sometimes I’d pass the room and catch a glimpse of her reflection—but not her body. Just her reflection.

One night, I decided to sleep in there. Dumb idea, I know. I brought my sleeping bag, my phone, and a flashlight. I wanted to film something. Maybe catch her on camera.

At 2:47 AM, the temperature dropped. Like, drastically. My flashlight flickered even though it had fresh batteries. Then I saw her. Not in the mirror—but sitting on the chair.

She looked at me and whispered, “He didn’t bury me.”

I couldn’t move. I couldn’t even breathe.

“He kept me here. Behind the wall. No rest. You have to help me.”

The next morning, I was sick. Fever, chills, no explanation. Mom called a priest. Not because she believed anything supernatural, but because “just in case.”

The priest came, looked at the mirror, looked at us, and said, “You need to dig.”

That part caught Dad off guard. “Dig where?”

The priest pointed to the floor beneath the mirror.

It took days to convince my parents. We finally borrowed tools and started breaking up the old tile. Underneath, we found bricks. And under the bricks, a small metal box.

Inside was a wedding ring, a locket, and a piece of torn fabric—stained and brittle. No bones. Just those things. We took them to the police, just in case. The detective looked skeptical, but took them anyway.

Weeks passed. Nothing happened. The woman didn’t appear again. I thought maybe we’d helped her somehow.

Then, the phone call came.

The detective told us they traced the locket to a missing person’s case from 1929. Her name was Lillian Monroe. She was engaged to Arthur Bellamy. The same man who wrote the journal.

But she vanished before the wedding. Everyone thought she’d run off. The case had gone cold nearly a century ago.

Apparently, Arthur reported her missing himself. But according to his own journal, she appeared in the mirror three days before her disappearance.

We went back to the journal and looked again. Sure enough, one entry said: “She appeared in the mirror today. But she’s not dead yet. I don’t understand. I don’t want it to be true. Not her.”

That’s when we realized something.

Arthur didn’t just see people before they died. He may have caused it. Or tried to stop it. The journal never made that clear. But Lillian’s locket hidden under the floor? That said enough.

We didn’t know what to do with the information. The police reclassified the case as a historical homicide, but with no body and no suspect alive, it went nowhere.

Still, something shifted in the house.

The air felt lighter. The mirror, though still cracked, didn’t feel threatening. We stopped having the dreams. The woman didn’t return.

Eventually, Dad built a proper cabinet around the mirror, more for safety than superstition. But he didn’t remove it.

“It’s part of the house,” he said. “And maybe part of her story now.”

Life went on. I went off to college. Mom started a blog about historical homes and included our story. It went viral. People were fascinated, and strangely, kind. No trolls, no skeptics tearing it down. Just comments like: “I hope she’s at peace now,” or “Thank you for sharing her story.”

A year later, something happened that none of us expected.

We got a letter.

It came from a woman in upstate New York who claimed to be Lillian Monroe’s grand-niece. Her grandmother had always said Lillian never ran away. That she’d been “taken” by someone, but no one believed her.

The locket confirmed everything. She even sent a photo. It was Lillian. The same face we’d seen in the mirror.

The woman—her name was Ruth—asked if she could visit the house. She said she wanted to see where Lillian had spent her last moments.

My parents were nervous, but agreed.

Ruth came a month later. She brought flowers, laid them in front of the mirror, and said a prayer. Then she turned to us and said, “I think she just wanted someone to tell the truth.”

We stood there for a long moment. Silent. It didn’t feel creepy anymore. It felt like closure.

Then Ruth gave us something.

It was an old black-and-white photo. Lillian and Arthur, smiling. Back when things were still good.

“I think she loved him,” Ruth said. “But something went wrong. Maybe he lost his mind. Maybe he believed the mirror too much.”

We framed the photo and hung it in the hallway. Right outside the hidden room.

It’s been four years since then.

Nothing strange has happened since.

No more dreams. No more whispers.

The room is still there, but we use it for storage now. The mirror stays behind the cabinet.

But I think about it sometimes. How some truths stay buried for years until they find the right people to uncover them.

And maybe, just maybe, some spirits don’t want revenge. They just want someone to listen.

There’s a lesson in that, I think.

That when something feels off, when there’s a voice no one else hears, it doesn’t always mean danger.

Sometimes, it means someone’s waiting for you to care enough to ask why.

We almost sealed that wall back up. Almost missed everything.

But a busted pipe, a curious heart, and a little bravery changed everything.

So next time you move into a place with a strange wall, maybe look behind it.

You never know whose story is still waiting to be told.

If this story touched you, don’t forget to like and share. Maybe someone you know needs to read it today.