Am I the a**hole for standing up in the middle of a church meeting and calling out the youth director in front of the entire congregation?
I (62F) have been raising my grandson Darius (11M) since he was four years old – his mom, my daughter Tanya, has been in and out of treatment, and his dad was never in the picture. Darius has cerebral palsy. He uses a forearm crutch and his speech is slow, but his mind is sharp as anyone’s. He’s been attending First Grace Fellowship since he was a baby. That church is supposed to be his second home.
The youth group director is a woman named Brenda Costas (44F), and she has been running the Wednesday night program for six years. Everyone loves her. She organizes the lock-ins, the mission trips, the holiday pageants. My family thinks she walks on water. I never had a problem with her until about eight months ago, when Darius started coming home from Wednesday nights quieter than usual.
I asked him what was wrong and he kept saying nothing. Then one Wednesday I showed up early to pick him up and he was sitting alone in the parking lot. Everyone else was still inside. I asked him why he was out there and he said Brenda told him the activity was “too physical” for him and asked him to wait outside until it was over.
That was the third time she’d done it.
I went inside and asked Brenda directly. She said she was “just being cautious” and that she “didn’t want Darius to feel embarrassed if he couldn’t keep up.” I told her that was not her call to make. She smiled at me – that tight little smile – and said, “We just want what’s best for all the kids.”
I went home and I didn’t say anything else. Not yet.
I started keeping notes after that. Dates, what activity, what Brenda said. I talked to two other parents whose kids had mentioned Darius sitting out. I asked Darius’s Sunday school teacher, who told me she’d seen it happen twice herself and felt uncomfortable but didn’t say anything.
Three weeks ago, the church held its quarterly family meeting – the whole congregation, parents, the pastor, the board, everyone in the main hall.
Brenda stood up to give her youth ministry report. She talked about community, about inclusion, about how the youth program was a place where every child belonged.
I had my folder in my lap.
My hands weren’t shaking.
Pastor Doug caught my eye from the front and I could tell he had no idea what was coming. My sister Vera grabbed my arm and said, “Donna, don’t.” My son-in-law texted me from two rows back: please don’t make a scene.
I stood up anyway.
The room went quiet. Brenda looked at me. And I opened that folder and said –
What I Actually Said
“Brenda, I appreciate your report. I’d like to add something to the record.”
That’s how I started. Quiet. I wasn’t yelling. I wasn’t crying. I’m 62 years old and I have sat across from social workers and judges and addiction counselors and I have learned that the quieter you are, the more people actually listen.
I said that I had been attending First Grace Fellowship for nineteen years. I said Darius had been coming since before he could walk at all, and that this congregation had held him at his baby dedication and had prayed for him through three surgeries. I said I needed the church to know what had been happening on Wednesday nights.
Then I read the dates.
September 14th. Relay race activity. Darius asked to wait in the hallway.
October 2nd. Obstacle course. Darius told it was “probably not a good fit for him tonight.”
October 23rd. That was the first time I found him in the parking lot. Alone. In the dark. Eleven years old, sitting on the curb with his crutch across his knees, waiting.
November 6th. Scavenger hunt through the building. He sat that one out too. A scavenger hunt. Walking through hallways looking for index cards. Too physical, apparently.
I read eight dates total. I had twelve in the folder but eight felt like enough.
The room was so quiet I could hear the heat kicking on through the vents.
The Tight Little Smile Disappeared
Brenda started to say something around the third date. She said, “I think there’s some context missing here,” and I said, “I’ll give you the floor when I’m finished,” and she sat back down.
Pastor Doug was gripping the edge of his chair.
When I got to October 23rd, the parking lot night, a woman three rows ahead of me put her hand over her mouth. I don’t know her name. She has twin boys who are in Darius’s age group. She knew exactly which night I was talking about.
When I finished, I closed the folder. I said that I was not there to end Brenda’s career or to burn anything down. I said I was there because my grandson had spent eight months being quietly, politely pushed to the edges of a community that was supposed to be his. I said he hadn’t told me how bad it was because he didn’t want to be a problem. An eleven-year-old with cerebral palsy had decided it was better to sit alone in a parking lot than to be a problem.
Then I sat down.
Vera had let go of my arm somewhere around the second date.
What Happened After
Brenda spoke. I’ll give her that. She didn’t run out of the room.
She said she had only ever tried to protect Darius from situations where he might get hurt or feel embarrassed. She said she had deep love for all the kids in her program. She said she was sorry if her decisions had made Darius feel excluded, that was never her intention.
If he felt excluded.
I didn’t respond to that. I let it sit there where everyone could look at it.
Pastor Doug called a short recess. Twenty minutes. People stood up and the noise level went from zero to a low, uncomfortable hum. My son-in-law Marcus came up from two rows back and stood next to me without saying anything. He’d been the one who texted me not to make a scene. He didn’t apologize for that and I didn’t ask him to.
Two parents came over. The woman with the twins, whose name turned out to be Gail, and a father named Keith whose daughter has a hearing aid and who said, very carefully, that he’d noticed some things too. He didn’t elaborate. He just nodded at me in a way that meant something.
My sister Vera got herself a cup of coffee from the side table and brought me one too. She said, “You had twelve dates in there?” I said yes. She said, “Why’d you stop at eight?” I said because by date eight, I could see that I didn’t need the other four.
When the meeting reconvened, Pastor Doug said the board would be meeting with Brenda and with me separately, and that the church was committed to making sure every child in its community felt fully included. He used the word committed twice. He’s a careful man, Pastor Doug. He chooses his words so they can’t be held against him later.
We’ll see what committed means when they’re sitting across from Brenda with six years of lock-ins and mission trips and holiday pageants on her side of the table.
What Darius Knows
He doesn’t know I did it.
I haven’t told him yet. He was at home with Marcus that night, playing Minecraft, and when I got back he asked if the meeting was boring and I said parts of it were pretty interesting and he said okay and went back to his game.
I’m not sure when I’ll tell him. Maybe when something actually changes. Maybe when I can say, “They fixed it, here’s what’s different now,” instead of just “I made a scene at church and now we wait.”
He asked me last week if he had to go to Wednesday night youth group anymore. Just asked it plain, like he was asking whether he had to eat his green beans. I said he didn’t have to go anywhere he didn’t want to go.
He said, “Okay,” and looked relieved in a way that hurt to see.
He’s eleven. He should be arguing with me about going, not relieved he doesn’t have to.
The thing about Darius is he doesn’t complain. He never has. When he was little and the other kids at the park would run and he couldn’t, he’d just find something else to do. He’d sit by the swings and draw in the dirt with a stick. I used to watch him do that and think, good, he’s adaptable, he’s resilient. And now I think: I should have been angrier sooner. I should have been the one who was loud so he didn’t have to learn to be quiet.
Am I the A**hole
My daughter-in-law thinks I embarrassed the family. She texted me that night: You could have handled that privately. My sister Vera, who grabbed my arm and told me not to, has since come around. She called me the next morning and said, “You were right, I just didn’t want the drama.” That’s honest, at least.
Two people from the congregation have reached out. Gail, the woman with the twins, sent me a message saying she was glad someone finally said something. Keith, the father with the hearing aid daughter, called and left a voicemail that was mostly silence and then him saying, “I should have said something a long time ago.”
I don’t know what the board will do. I don’t know if Brenda will be retrained or reprimanded or if Pastor Doug will find a way to smooth this over and call it resolved by Easter. I’ve been around long enough to know that institutions protect themselves and call it grace.
What I know is this: I have kept notes on my grandson being excluded from his own church for eight months. I talked to other parents. I talked to his Sunday school teacher. I gave Brenda a chance to correct it privately when I showed up in that parking lot and looked her in the eye and told her it was not her call to make.
She smiled at me and said they just wanted what was best for all the kids.
So yes. I stood up in the middle of a church meeting. I read eight dates out loud in a room of two hundred people. I did it without shaking and without crying and without apologizing.
And my grandson sat home playing Minecraft not knowing any of it was happening, which is exactly how it should be.
He’s already done enough waiting in parking lots.
—
If this one stayed with you, pass it along to someone who’d get it.
If you’re still reeling from this tale, you’ll find similar vibes in I Stood Up in the Middle of a Church Service and Said His Name Out Loud, or perhaps dig into the emotional depths of I Followed a Stranger Off a Bus Because She Looked Like My Dead Sister. And for another story of family drama and church leadership, check out My Brother Made a Packing List for the Trip They Secretly Banned Him From.
