My MIL Gave Everything To Her Other Daughter—Then Demanded We Fund Her Retirement

“My MIL gave everything to her other daughter and now demands that my husband and I fund her retirement. I refused. She screamed, ‘You ungrateful brats will regret it!’ I called her bluff. The next day, my husband came home late. He called me in tears: ‘You must come to Mom’s house right now…’”

I dropped everything and raced over, heart pounding so hard I could hear it in my ears. Traffic blurred past like it didn’t matter. In that moment, nothing did—except figuring out why my usually calm, steady husband, Alden, was crying on the phone like a lost child.

When I got there, the front door was wide open. I walked in, calling his name, and found him on the floor of the kitchen, just sitting. His hands were covering his face. His mother sat at the table, eerily quiet, just sipping tea like she hadn’t just turned our lives upside down.

“She signed everything over, Anisa,” Alden said without looking up. “The house, her savings, even the car. All of it to Tahlia. And now it’s all gone.”

Gone?

He pulled out a crumpled letter from the table, hand-written and barely legible. Apparently, Tahlia—his older sister—had sold the house two weeks ago. Not just listed it. Sold it. Cashed the accounts too. She was gone, and so was every cent their mother had handed over “to keep things in the family.”

And now she expected us to pick up the pieces.

The worst part? We knew this was coming.

For years, Alden’s mom, Ritha, had made it clear that Tahlia was the golden child. She could do no wrong—even after two bankruptcies, three failed businesses, and a string of short-lived relationships that always ended in some kind of financial disaster.

Alden and I, on the other hand, had built everything ourselves. We didn’t make a lot, but we were stable. We worked hard, saved smart, and still found a way to help his mom when she needed it. Groceries, medical appointments, even helping with bills once or twice.

But when it came time for Ritha to write her will, she said it outright: “Tahlia needs it more. You two are fine.”

We didn’t argue. We let it go. You can’t reason with favoritism.

But what we didn’t expect was for Ritha to come knocking six months later, practically demanding that we take her in now that her “retirement plan” had evaporated with her daughter.

“I didn’t know she’d betray me,” she said, holding her tea with shaky hands. “She said she’d take care of me.”

Alden looked like his soul had left his body.

“You made your choice, Ma,” he said, standing slowly. “Now you want us to clean it up.”

“You’re my son,” she snapped. “I gave birth to you! You owe me!”

I stepped in then, keeping my voice calm. “We’ve helped you every time you asked. But you gave away everything we might have used to help you. And now… now we have a baby coming, Ritha. We can’t—”

“You selfish girl,” she spat. “This is what I get for raising you like a daughter?”

It hit me harder than it should’ve. Because once upon a time, I had tried. To win her over. To be the “other daughter” she might accept. But I was never going to be Tahlia.

We left that night without agreeing to anything. I told Alden we needed space to think. He nodded, but he was quiet all the way home.

For two weeks, we didn’t hear from her. No calls, no texts. Alden checked in with a neighbor to make sure she was alive. She was fine—just stewing.

Then one Saturday morning, we got a visit.

Not from her.

From Adult Protective Services.

They’d received an anonymous report claiming we were “abandoning an elderly woman in distress.”

I thought I was going to be sick.

Alden sat through the interview with a knot in his jaw, answering every question calmly. The woman from APS was polite, even a little embarrassed. Once she saw that Ritha didn’t live with us, and that she still had her faculties, the whole thing dissolved quickly.

Still, the damage was done.

I couldn’t un-hear what she’d said to them. That we were “leaving her to starve.” That her “greedy daughter-in-law” was “keeping her son away.”

She tried to pin the whole betrayal on me.

“I want to go no-contact,” I told Alden that night. “For our sanity. For the baby. She’ll never stop.”

He nodded.

But I could tell he wasn’t fully ready.

I didn’t blame him. That’s the thing about parents—even toxic ones. They shape you. Twist guilt around your ribs until it feels like breathing.

Three months passed. We had a baby girl. We named her Imani.

Ritha didn’t come to the hospital. Didn’t send a message. Nothing.

It should’ve made things easier.

But one afternoon, when I was nursing on the couch and hadn’t slept in 26 hours, I caught Alden sitting on the porch. Holding his phone. Just staring at her number.

“She’s still your mom,” I said gently. “But we have to protect us first.”

He didn’t call.

Then, two weeks later, the twist we never saw coming.

Alden received a letter from a lawyer.

Apparently, Ritha had taken out a reverse mortgage on her house before she handed it to Tahlia. And the bank was now trying to collect.

The house had already been sold to a new owner, and because of some wildly shady paperwork, Alden’s name had ended up on some of the documentation—because he’d helped her file for Medicaid once and signed as her healthcare proxy.

Now the bank wanted him to pay up.

I thought I was going to pass out.

We called a lawyer immediately. Thankfully, he was good. He dug through the mess and untangled Alden’s liability—turns out, he wasn’t financially responsible. But it cost us nearly $4,000 in legal fees just to clear his name.

Ritha never apologized.

Never even acknowledged what she’d done.

But something unexpected happened after that.

Tahlia returned.

Not with an apology. But with a swollen eye, two black suitcases, and a story that would’ve been hilarious if it hadn’t been so pathetic.

She’d fallen for a guy in Miami. Moved in. Gave him control over the money “to invest.” You can guess the rest. The money was gone. He was gone. And now she was back in town, sleeping on someone’s couch.

I half-expected Ritha to welcome her home with open arms.

Instead, Ritha refused to let her in.

“She used me,” she said coldly. “She can rot for all I care.”

That’s when it hit me.

She’d spent her whole life enabling Tahlia, and when the golden child finally cut the cord—for real—Ritha panicked. And then she turned on us.

It was never about love. Just about who could give her what she needed.

Even Alden saw it now.

We didn’t let Tahlia move in either. But we offered her a ride to a women’s shelter that helped people rebuild after financial abuse. She sneered, called me a few choice names, and stormed off.

Fine.

That chapter was done.

And slowly, finally, peace started to return.

We focused on Imani. On each other. On healing. We even took a short weekend trip to the mountains—a gift from Alden’s boss who’d heard the whole story and said, “You two need a break.”

But life wasn’t done teaching us yet.

Six months later, Alden got a call.

Ritha had been found wandering the street, confused. Turns out she’d suffered a mini-stroke. The hospital needed to know: were we willing to take her in?

It felt like déjà vu.

This time, we didn’t argue. We offered to pay for her to stay in a recovery facility—for a limited time. We weren’t cold. We just weren’t stupid.

She fought it at first. Threw a fit in the ER, called Alden every name in the book.

But when she realized we weren’t budging, she stopped.

And something shifted.

Maybe it was the stroke. Maybe it was realizing she had no one left to manipulate. But for the first time in ten years, Ritha stopped yelling.

She stayed in the facility for eight weeks.

And then, one rainy Thursday, she asked to see Imani.

I was hesitant.

Alden was too.

But we took her, supervised.

Ritha sat quietly in her wheelchair, hands folded in her lap. Watched Imani stack colorful blocks with big, clumsy baby hands.

“She’s beautiful,” she said softly.

We didn’t reply.

And then she looked at me.

“I was cruel to you.”

It wasn’t much.

But it was more than I ever expected.

She didn’t become warm overnight. She didn’t become a doting grandma. But she became quiet. And still. And—on rare days—kind.

We kept our boundaries.

We paid for her care, but not at the cost of our sanity. We made peace without pretending history hadn’t happened.

And slowly, we found a new rhythm.

Alden told me one night, “You know what? She doesn’t get to define what kind of parents we are. Or what kind of peace we build.”

I nodded.

Because he was right.

Family doesn’t always mean fairness. And forgiveness doesn’t mean forgetting. But it can mean freedom.

For anyone in a similar mess: protect your peace. Choose your circle. And don’t feel guilty for building the life your parents should have taught you to want.

Thanks for reading. If this resonated with you, please like and share—it might help someone else feel less alone.